There was a collective groan that overcame the sports world on Sunday night when Cam Newton walked away from his press conference following the Carolina Panthers 24-10 loss to the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl 50. The groan was split into two separate, yet equally important camps: The folks who were waiting for Newton to trip up and the folks who were sure he would not. His actions played right into the narrative that Newton, the league’s newly minted MVP, was not mature enough to be the leader of the best team in the NFL.

Every move that Cam Newton has made since leaving high school in 2007 has been examined under the lens of America’s obsessive sports media. He was kicked out of the University of Florida’s football program after allegedly stealing another student’s laptop. He endured accusations that he accepted a large sum of money to play Division I football again after leading Blinn College to a National Junior College championship. Leading up to and following the 2011 NFL Draft, Newton dealt with skeptics’ claims that he could never be a winner on Sundays – he wasn’t going to cut it as a pocket passer.

Nearly five years since that draft day, Newton was on the verge of proving his critics wrong. He still has his Heisman Trophy, the one that so many predicted would be taken away just as Reggie Bush’s award once was, and was crowned the league’s most valuable player the night before playing in the biggest game of his life. But after failing to guide his team to its first-ever Vince Lombardi Trophy, his critics feel justified by his actions on and off the field.


On April 18, 1998, the Indianapolis Colts ignored the hype about Ryan Leaf and made the comparatively safe Peyton Manning the top pick in that year’s NFL Draft. He wasn’t agile enough for some scouts, and many people were convinced that Leaf would end up as the better quarterback. One AFC personnel man said Manning was “too frigging serious” and concluded that picking Archie Manning’s son first overall would be akin to Cleveland’s decision to pick Mike Phipps with the third pick in the 1970 draft.

The Indianapolis Star‘s front-page story on Colts’ GM Bill Polian’s selection of Manning mentioned that the Colts had to hope that Peyton’s squeaky clean image wasn’t too good to be true. After all, it was those intangibles that made him the superior pick to Leaf. Leaf had a better arm and what most people considered to be a higher talent ceiling. To justify taking Manning, the 3-13 Colts had to be convinced he was ready to play in the NFL right away, and be convinced that Leaf was not.

Manning dealt with a tremendous amount of pressure early in his career. He threw 28 interceptions in his rookie campaign, and the Colts finished 3-13 for a second year in a row. The pressure lessened as Leaf struggled even more, starting just nine games in 1998, and throwing just two touchdowns while tossing 15 picks. The on-field criticisms wouldn’t become pronounced until he was unable topple the Belichick empire in 2004 and 2005.

Those criticisms were pronounced loudly during those years, though. His playoff struggles would lead many to consider him a soft QB who couldn’t handle big games or tough weather. They felt he needed to play in Indy’s weather-shielded home stadium to find success. Finally, in January 2007, Peyton Manning had his chance to exorcise his demons. After mounting a comeback from an 18-point deficit against the Patriots, Manning and the Colts pulled off a miraculous last-minute drive to beat New England, 38-34, winning the AFC Championship. The victory put the Colts in the Super Bowl for the first time since they had moved to Indianapolis.

Manning, who had won the league’s MVP award twice in the three seasons leading up to Super Bowl XLI, was the game’s MVP in a rain-soaked 29-17 win over the Chicago Bears that wasn’t as close as the score indicated. He hadn’t required a dome, and he hadn’t choked on the game’s biggest stage. While he told reporters that he wasn’t “into monkeys and vindication,” there was an overwhelming feeling that he had removed a sizable primate from his back.

Now, almost a decade since that Super Bowl victory, Manning has won another NFL title. He has done so amid allegations of HGH use following a career-threatening neck injury and swirling rumors of his impending retirement. The media have been on Peyton like a hawk in the last few years about retirement, but the hounding came to a head when he and his teammates started celebrating their championship. To their chagrin, Manning gave media members non-answers and thinly veiled endorsements of Budweiser. Any hope of Manning riding off into the San Fran sunset was dashed by his perceived professionalism.


Super Bowl 50 brought together the two best defenses in the National Football League. They slugged it out for 60 minutes on a mild San Francisco night, and when the game clock registered all zeroes, Peyton Manning’s Broncos had come out on top. That’s the story of the game in arguably its simplest form. But we don’t want simple. We want it all.

We yearn for the details and story-lines that weave the game into a gripping event. People mock the two-week delay between the league’s conference championships and the Super Bowl, but it builds everything to a towering crescendo that we can’t ignore. We eat up every single moment of coverage that’s thrown at us: Media Day, pregame shows, the opinions of former players. If we didn’t consume it all, they wouldn’t bother to produce it.

This year, more than any other before it, was less about what was happening on the field than off of it. Turn on ESPN or hit your favorite sports website, and you’ll see that the prominent coverage of Super Bowl 50 focuses on two people: Peyton Manning and Cam Newton. You don’t even have to dig to realize that the moments people are focusing on didn’t even happen during the game: Peyton Manning didn’t say whether he would retire, and Cam Newton walked off in the middle of his post-game presser.

Never mind the incredible play of Von Miller, who forced two fumbles in a smothering defensive effort by the Broncos, and you can’t forget about how impressive Panthers’ cornerback Josh Norman was while suffocating Denver’s passing attack. Those things are practically forgotten in the mire of microphones and audio recorders that are being shoved in the faces of two quarterbacks that are experiencing life-altering moments.

While it may have been turned up to eleven in the last few days, this trend of words meaning more than actions in sports has been occurring for years. It’s gotten downright absurd: Interviews after games have been a staple for decades, but MLB on FOX broadcasts now regularly feature Q-and-A sessions with managers during the baseball games they are managing. Most of the time, these pointless interviews feature banal questions and clichéd answers, yielding little of value for anyone involved.

But every once in a while, you get a golden nugget: The media catches someone right after they’ve just given every ounce of energy they had to their sport, and that person says or does something at least moderately surprising.


We have bizarre expectations of professional athletes. Richard Sherman’s post-game interview (above) from the Seattle Seahawks’ NFC Championship Game win over San Francisco in 2014 is probably the greatest example. Sherman had less than a minute to collect himself before Erin Andrews cheerfully came over with a microphone to ask him to recount the final play of the game. Somehow people were surprised that the guy who is paid to tackle other grown men at high speed for a living couldn’t pull it all together less than sixty seconds after doing exactly that.

Peyton Manning faced a similar situation after winning the second Super Bowl of his career on Sunday. Immediately following the final snap, he was bombarded with reporters and cameramen. He gave his obligatory interview to CBS, where he was asked whether he would ever again play the game he has loved for his entire life. Because, you know, who has time to celebrate being a champion when millions of strangers want to know what’s next for the guy? His answer was predictably circular and cliché-ridden, avoiding any commitment to his plans for the future. It was the carefully crafted, professional answer we all feared: An overwrought “no comment.”

Cam Newton, on the other hand, fed right into what we want. We placed him on a literal pedestal, and he ran off of it. He got frustrated with the media over the last few weeks (probably even longer than that), and while the rumors of Chris Harris, Jr.’s comments driving Newton from the podium may be true, can we really blame him if it was truly a disinterest in speaking to the media? He just lost the biggest game of his life, and he knows the questions are going to be pointed at him. He’s dealt with detractors since day one, and he knows they’re giddy with excitement at his failure to deliver a trophy to Charlotte. We eat up that kind of drama, and the media serves it up in droves.


I wrote the first two sections of this piece (on Cam Newton and Peyton Manning’s early careers) almost entirely from prior knowledge of the two players. I say this to acknowledge that I feed right into the very machine I am here to harp against. Those stories are exciting and dramatic, and they are what keep us engrossed in sports even during the offseason. We treasure them because we get to say, “Look, those guys aren’t perfect after all!” We bring them down to our level, but it’s just for a moment.

The reason they even fall from those pedestals is that we put them there in the first place. We envision that all of our favorite athletes are perfect people that will never let us down. We imagine their lives as pristine; after all, they have that money and fame that we crave. Any time they act uncomfortable with that game or fortune, we cry, “That’s what you signed up for!”

I once aspired to play professional sports in my life, but I never dreamed of being bombarded with questions about every minute error and mistake, let alone as a requirement by my employer. And while “money can’t buy happiness” is a tired adage, it is so because it’s true. No matter how many hundred-dollar bills make up a person’s mattress, it’s hard to sleep under the stress of the American sports media. Sometimes, it’s just too much to contain all that frustration, and athletes, who are trained to be aggressive and tenacious, exhume their buried frustration in front of microphones and cameras.

It’s unfair to expect professional athletes to be professional spokespeople, and it’s worse to be shocked when they are not. I love the drama of sports, but when we are goading players into creating drama, it’s not worth it. There’s plenty of drama available within the game and the processes that go along with it, i.e. amateur drafts and free agency. We don’t need to be adding to it by trying to pry controversial responses from the lips of the distracted.

8 thoughts on “Time to pull back the microphone”

  1. I precisely had to thank you so much all over again. I’m not certain the things that I would have taken care of in the absence of the entire ways provided by you directly on such field. It had become an absolute difficult condition in my view, nevertheless observing your well-written manner you solved the issue took me to weep over gladness. I’m just happier for your assistance and in addition have high hopes you comprehend what an amazing job your are carrying out teaching some other people thru your web site. More than likely you have never come across all of us.

  2. I in addition to my pals were reading the nice secrets located on the website and all of the sudden developed an awful feeling I never expressed respect to the web blog owner for them. My boys appeared to be absolutely glad to read all of them and now have absolutely been tapping into these things. Appreciation for really being very kind and also for using these kinds of perfect tips most people are really desirous to understand about. My very own sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to earlier.

  3. I simply wanted to thank you so much once more. I do not know the things I might have gone through without the type of pointers shown by you relating to such area. Previously it was an absolute traumatic setting for me personally, however , taking a look at the professional way you treated that made me to weep with gladness. I am just happy for your support and even wish you recognize what a great job that you’re providing educating people via your websites. Most probably you haven’t met all of us.

  4. I simply wished to say thanks all over again. I am not sure what I would have gone through in the absence of the entire tricks shared by you concerning such problem. Previously it was a real depressing case for me personally, nevertheless spending time with a new specialised way you dealt with the issue took me to leap with joy. I am just thankful for the advice and pray you are aware of an amazing job that you are providing instructing the mediocre ones through your webblog. Most probably you have never come across any of us.

  5. My husband and i were now comfortable that Peter managed to conclude his studies through the entire precious recommendations he obtained when using the weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just always be giving out secrets that many others might have been selling. Therefore we see we’ve got the blog owner to thank because of that. The main illustrations you made, the straightforward site navigation, the friendships you can give support to create – it is all fantastic, and it is making our son in addition to us know that the article is amusing, and that’s particularly serious. Many thanks for all!

  6. Thanks for each of your hard work on this web page. Kate delights in managing internet research and it is easy to see why. Many of us learn all regarding the compelling medium you convey invaluable secrets through this website and even encourage response from other ones about this idea while our favorite princess is really studying a lot. Enjoy the rest of the new year. You’re the one doing a tremendous job.

  7. I really wanted to write a simple comment so as to say thanks to you for all of the awesome information you are showing at this site. My rather long internet search has at the end been honored with extremely good strategies to go over with my family members. I ‘d point out that we visitors are unquestionably fortunate to dwell in a superb network with many brilliant professionals with interesting principles. I feel truly grateful to have discovered the web site and look forward to plenty of more thrilling minutes reading here. Thank you once again for a lot of things.

  8. I simply wished to thank you very much once more. I’m not certain the things I would have gone through in the absence of the creative concepts provided by you about this area of interest. Previously it was a intimidating crisis in my view, nevertheless taking a look at the very well-written avenue you processed it took me to jump with joy. I’m just thankful for your assistance and as well , sincerely hope you comprehend what a powerful job you are accomplishing instructing the rest through the use of your site. I know that you’ve never come across any of us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *